The Shame of Ireland

The Shame of Ireland

Abuse survivors report 'huge fear' of visits to hospitals and institutions

Abuse survivors report 'huge fear' of visits to hospitals and institutions

That’s according to a new report published today.

Image: Shutterstock/Tamara Borgia

SURVIVORS OF ABUSE in residential institutions have said health needs, housing and social supports are of concern to them, according to a new report

The facilitators of the report engaged with over 100 people and held over 30 meetings in Ireland and the UK over the course of the past six months leading up to its publication today. 

Among the issues highlighted in the report are the increased health needs of an aging population, concerns about adequate and suitable housing, social supports to counteract social isolation and the need to make services easier to access. 

Survivors concerns in Ireland, in order of priority, include:

  • An aging profile and increased health needs
  • Fear of institutionalisation in old age (hospitals, nursing homes etc.)
  • Adequate and suitable housing
  • Poverty – inadequate income
  • Fear of isolation and the need for social supports
  • Neglecting the needs of ‘hard to reach’ survivors
  • The restrictions on obtaining counselling services
  • Support in managing bureaucracy to access services
  • The unequal treatment of survivors who didn’t receive redress and therefore couldn’t access services and funds through Caranua.
  • Lack of educational support for survivors and for their children and grandchildren
  • Lack of access to information and files on their own and their families’ histories
  • Being seen as ‘helpless victims’ rather than ‘resilient people’ who survived despite the lack of adequate support
  • Resettlement options for survivors who returned to or wish to return to Ireland

Priority needs

For both Irish and UK residents, health, end of life care, housing, social supports and finance are paramount, according to the report. 

Survivors communicated a huge fear of being forced into an institution at the end of their life and visits to hospitals were described as traumatic.

They are asking for several measures to be implemented including home care packages that consider their circumstances, consultations about how to meet end of life needs and assurances that funeral expenses will be available.

Counselling has been noted as extremely important by both Irish and UK residents and fears were expressed that access to counselling has been reduced.

Both Irish and UK survivors have expressed strong needs for adequate housing. Many survivors who are resident in the UK live in poor-quality housing.

Survivors and advocates stress the importance of helping them achieve a high qualifying level for social housing.

Pension rights are important in both the UK and Ireland, according to the report.

Wishes for an enhanced pension entitlement that would not impact on welfare benefits and entitlements are important in the UK.

In Ireland, survivors wished to obtain a contributory pension to acknowledge the years spent working in Irish institutions without payment.

Aging population

The report noted that 80% of survivors are aged over 58. Just over half of these are over the age of 70 and 7% are over the age of 80. 

One survivor/advocate advised that a thorough assessment of survivors changing needs should be conducted without delay in both Ireland and the UK.

They suggested that those doing the assessments need to be trained in conducting them and be competent in communicating with survivors.

The researchers didn’t engage with survivors outside the UK and Ireland. However, they were told by other survivors that age-related health issues are experienced by survivors in both the US and Canada.

“These survivors would like a dedicated website which keeps them up to date on survivor issues. While this was available in the past, it had to close due to lack of funding,” the report noted. 

Both survivors and advocates stated that many survivors in both the UK and Ireland often live relatively isolated lives. They do not trust people easily and value face-to-face contact and a building of trust over time, according to the report.

Therefore, the provision of drop-in centres that are friendly, hospitable and well-run is vital for the positive mental health of survivors, the report stated. 

Survivors and advocates say that these centres can double up as a signpost to other services like health, housing and other benefits.

Survivor-led consultation group

Most survivors that the researchers heard from thought that a survivor-led consultation group which could engage with the government to get needs of survivors had a lot of merit. 

They said that survivors knew the issues of concern to survivors best.

However, they were also sceptical of “what would come out of it, having been down that road before” and being disappointed by the cancellation and postponement of meetings led by various government departments, the report noted. 

They stated that this type of process would benefit from an independent chair and/or an independent facilitator.

The report noted that it would be important that there would be a liaison and administrative support from the government. Those participating in this group would need to be resourced with their travel and subsistence costs, it stated. 

Commenting on the report, Minister for Education Joe McHugh thanked the survivors who engaged with the independent report facilitators, Barbara Walshe and Catherine O’Connell. 

“The report is clear and unambiguous in articulating the views of those consulted. The report talks about the importance of survivors’ voices being heard and I want to support that,” McHugh said. 

As regards the next steps, the Minister said: “I want to acknowledge the clear call from survivors to move on from further widespread consulting about needs and to begin a process of engagement about how those needs can be met.

“The report proposes the establishment of a survivor-led group to assist in this. I would like to see this group established as soon as possible.”

The Minister is requesting the interdepartmental committee to establish early contact with the group.

“On foot of that engagement, I am anxious to see clear proposals for action which I can bring to my colleagues in government,” McHugh said.

Source -

Views: 134

Comment by Cathriona Barker on August 4, 2019 at 21:22
Rob Northall. You have been keeping survivors up to date on everything for over 10 years, I must know you 10 years or even more and you and Robert Artane are the real people who has been there for us! You both should be acknowledged for your hard work and kindness.
Comment by Theresa Newberry on August 9, 2019 at 4:17

Thank you for posting this, Barbie. I will be back when having more time to read it all, it's alot (the whole new report). Can relate to much of this and particular area of interest is:

  • Resettlement options for survivors who returned to or wish to return to Ireland

Comment by pauline jackson on August 10, 2019 at 16:43

Its more than fear Its panic. Even filling out forms brings on hot and cold sweats. Going to hospitals and clinics is frightening. There is always the 1 or 2 people giving out orders and always 1 or 2 perverts making people suffer in very suptle ways.Being handicapped i have spent over an hour sitting on toilets because no one had the time to get me off. This by smiling nurses.Yet because of my 9 years in goldenbridge i see this kind of thing as torture and i get very upset. What kind of future awaits me.Well i know. its a medicalised old peoples hospital.How do i feel about this well i hope to die quickly.There is no support for isolated survivors.We have to find our own answers.

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of The Shame of Ireland to add comments!

Join The Shame of Ireland


Rob Northall created this Ning Network.



This is a Private Site

Membership is drawn from Survivors of the Irish Industrial School System their Family and Friends. Survivors of the Magdalene Laundries their Families and Friends are welcome too!

Others can follow on Twitter by Clicking the Button Bellow

Follow ShameOfIreland on Twitter

 Follow on FACE BOOK by Clicking <HERE>

Please Like this FACE BOOK Page?


  • Add Photos
  • View All



© 2023   Created by Rob Northall.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service