The Shame of Ireland

The Shame of Ireland

Almost two complaints a week were made against Caranua last year by survivors of institutional child abuse.


Caranua was established by the Residential Institutions Statutory Fund Act 2012 to oversee the use of the cash contributions of up to €110m, pledged by the religious congregations, to support the needs of survivors of institutional child abuse.

The fund is to provide survivors with their health, educational and housing needs.

Figures released under Freedom of Information show that, between April 2015 and February of this year, 75 formal complaints were made by survivors about the service offered by Caranua — almost two every week. The vast majority relate to “disrespectful/poor treatment”. However, others include “failure to protect confidentiality”, “discriminatory treatment” and “failure to meet timeline”.


Tom Cronin of Irish Survivors of Institutional Abuse International said he believed the figures to be “the tip of the iceberg”.

“ A lot of survivors are vulnerable and timid and don’t bother to complain. If Caranua is working, then why are so many survivors unhappy with it? We are just ignored. It’s a situation where we have to beg for our own money — money that we are entitled to. It’s disgraceful what they are doing,” he said.

Mr Cronin said the system was “completely ad hoc” and that while surivivors could get money for certain home renovations, finance for essential white goods like fridges, washing machines, and cookers was denied.

He also queried Caranua’s refusal to release money to survivors who wanted finance to help pay for their own burials.

“Many survivors are worse off now than they were when they received the redress awards. In their twilight years, survivors are being denied what was awarded to them by bureacracy,” he said.

Mr Cronin said he believed the State was hoping survivors would die off so the fund could be closed and re-directed into other areas.

A spokesperson for Caranua denied the level of complaints was high and said that it was always working to make the application process more survivor centred.

“Ideally, we would have no complaints. However, of the over 5,180 part one applications we have received up to February, that figure [75 complaints] represents about 1.5%.

“Obviously, we want that figure down to 0%. In general, we are always trying to iron out our processess to make them as person centred as possible. We talk to a lot of survivors and groups and we are always trying to adapt to best suit the needs of the people we are supporting,” she said.

The spokesperson acknowledged that goods and money for burial was not permitted under the current guidelines but said that, due to survivors’ concerns on this issue, it was “currently under review”.

She also denied that there was any intention to close the fund before all the money has been spent.

“We don’t intend to have any money left over as we can see that the need is there for the money to be spent in the survivor population and that is our intention. As of today, we have spent around €45m in different supports out of the €110m so we are going through it rapidly,” she said.

Caranua will hold an information meeting in Cork on April 23 and Galway on May 14, and is encouraging as many potential applicants as possible to attend.

© Irish Examiner Ltd. All rights reserved

Thank You for Reading!

Suggested Reading

“Survivor Meeting with Mary Higgins, CEO New Statutory Trust Fund” ...

While you can read this as a Public Post
only Members can comment!

Click <Here> to Sign up?

Views: 1101

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Just been looking at caranua website and guess what they are recruiting,  they say they need another 16 posts was wondering who will be paying their salaries,  if their salaries are coming from our fund,  the money will be gone pretty damn fast. Have a pleasant weekend everyone. 

Of course we are funding it, power play from power mad mary higgins, feathering her nest for post caranua, shes part of a ceo networking group whos aim is to advance each others careers where ever possible, 

Hi Elizabeth, all employees for top to bottom are paid their wages and salaries for the Caranua Fund - that is us the Survivors are the employers of all staff at caranua. When you look at the overall figures of what has been spent from the fund this would include the salaries of the CEO down to the person on the other end of the phone, they are getting more money from the fund than the Survivors. Barbara
Elizabeth Nicholas said:

Just been looking at caranua website and guess what they are recruiting,  they say they need another 16 posts was wondering who will be paying their salaries,  if their salaries are coming from our fund,  the money will be gone pretty damn fast. Have a pleasant weekend everyone. 

Today I have spoken to donall O'Fartharta  Senior Reported at the Irish Examiner.

Have  any of you received abusive letter from M. Higgins or other menbers of Caranua that you find abusive towards you. He is happy to look at these and hopefully compile them and move forward. Unless we expose them and their ABUSE we will fall foul once again to the Irish Establishment.  I am waiting for confirmation from Donall and I will post his details on site.

Kathleen O'Malley.

Kathleen O'Malley. said:

Maureen.  this is one area I believe Survivors or probably Irish Nationals are hesitant about for fear of dipping their toes in  hot water. After all what happened to us as children if we so much as uttered a suggestion "beaten into submission" Old Habits die Hard" So yes let us be as one.


Maureen sullivan said:

You know what's is important here is that survivors stick togeather stand united and we will go a long way ,
Regards Maureen Sullivan

Hello all,  have just ben reading this message from Connall O' Fatharta of the Irish Examiner Newspaper again as I read it too fast the first time,  the spokesperson said that guide lines were currently under review, so does that mean that this woman made the guidelines up in the first instant.  She also said that they do not intend to have any money left over,  they wont , because it will be used up in salaries and pensions,  this lot has to be stopped so ladies and gents if   you have a grievence with these people stand up and let this journalist know in writing and maybe maybe we will get what is totally ours,   so come on my friends don't be afraid of being punished by this caranua lot we are stronger than that.



Rob Northall created this Ning Network.


Birthdays Today


This is a Private Site

Membership is drawn from Survivors of the Irish Industrial School System their Family and Friends. Survivors of the Magdalene Laundries their Families and Friends are welcome too!

Others can follow on Twitter by Clicking the Button Bellow

Follow ShameOfIreland on Twitter

 Follow on FACE BOOK by Clicking <HERE>

Please Like this FACE BOOK Page?


  • Add Photos
  • View All



© 2023   Created by Rob Northall.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service