The Shame of Ireland

The Shame of Ireland

Michael power 's Comments

Comment Wall (21 comments)

At 15:29 on May 31, 2016, jack colleton said…

Welcome Michael!

At 18:49 on May 31, 2016, Michael power said…
Reply from Mary Higgins
Please accept my apologies, it appears that this was not replied to.

You may be right about all of these things, but we have to operate under the legislation. If you have complaints about the legislation they will need to be addressed to the Minister.

The specific answers are that we cannot provide support to someone who is not eligible to apply to us, so we cannot provide something that is for your child, because he is not an eligible applicant. A fitted kitchen might conceivably be covered under housing but it isn’t and yes, paying for a wedding could well improve someone’s health and wellbeing but it is not covered by the Guidelines.

I hope this answers your questions. Please do contact Stephanie about your application.

Yours sincerely

Mary Higgins
Chief Executive Officer
At 19:10 on May 31, 2016, micheal said…

They are ignoring terminaly ill survivors, refusing survivors recommended medical care, and stomping all over survivors human rights, tell king Mary put that one in her pipe and smoke it while she banks survivors money to her own bank account. Michael

At 15:11 on June 1, 2016, Elizabeth Nicholas said…

the last minister did not want to know about caranua or change Legislation even though the Irish Government set it up so who do we ask for help now to change Legislation does anyone in the Government or caranua really care about us.

At 12:50 on June 2, 2016, Michael power said…
Reply I got from last Minister; Dear Mr. Power,

The Minister for Education and Skills Ms. Jan O’Sullivan TD has asked me to refer again to your recent e-mail in relation to your application to Caranua - the Residential Institutions Statutory Fund.

The Minister has asked me to explain that Caranua is an independent statutory body established pursuant to the Residential Institutions Statutory Fund Act 2012 to oversee the use of the cash contributions of up to €110 million, pledged by the religious congregations, to support the needs of survivors of institutional child abuse. Eligibility to receive support from Caranua is restricted to those 15,000 former residents who have received awards from the Residential Institutions Redress Board or equivalent Court awards. The 2012 Act does not provide for the eligibility of relatives of survivors of abuse to receive support from Caranua. This approach was taken having regard to the maximum funds available and the potential pool of applicants.

The Minister has also asked me to point out that the 2012 Act sets out the classes of services from which approved services can be determined by Caranua. These classes of services are mental health services, health and personal social services and education and housing services. It is a matter for Caranua to determine the criteria by reference to which it will make decisions on applications. The Minister has no role in relation to the determination of criteria or application guidelines approved by Caranua nor does she have a role in relation to the organisation’s day to day operations including the processing of applications and decisions on individual applications.

The Minister trusts that this information will be of assistance to you.

Yours sincerely,

Sean Tansey
Private Secretary
At 13:18 on June 2, 2016, micheal said…

If they really want to get max from the fund return their very large wages which they have taken from the fund, we are fighting a cause here for homeless survivors with mental health issues, survivors with medical needs survivors who have little to nothing while millions are pocketed in wages,  so i ask you in stead of pasting responses what are your views on these issues.

At 23:02 on June 2, 2016, Michael power said…
I think they should be looking into survivors needs and see how they can really help them, not setting creitera what they can and can't get,
At 23:25 on June 2, 2016, micheal said…

Exactly how would they know what a survivor needs, despite what there telling the media, there leaving homeless survivors with mental health issues on the street, over riding medical recommendations to deny survivors treatment,  so they do not have survivors best interests at heart. 

At 0:00 on June 3, 2016, Mark said…

I have a bad feeling that the new guidelines will even harder on us lads higgins head just burys itself deeper in the sand

At 8:49 on June 3, 2016, Michael power said…
They should be meeting us face to face, so we can explain or needs, they could role it out to the community welfare officers and I wouldn't cost them a penny, what happens this 110 million if it not claimed, who pocket does it go into, is that why there making it so hard for people
At 9:06 on June 3, 2016, micheal said…

Thats a good idea, they could of used staff already paid by the government, face to face would be a key element in getting to know a person, i think any monies unclaimed will be used as wages under the pretext of  waiting for new survivors to apply. I think this final wage bill if the new 16 staff are brought on board could run to as much as 10% of the entire fund. Michael

At 16:08 on July 2, 2016, james fox said…

i didn't think you could get white goods under the caranua scheme i was refused a fridge

cooker carpit armchairs and every thing that could make my life better i need a walking 

stick just to stand up .james 

At 16:06 on July 3, 2016, james fox said…

thank you michael . can i sign up to the new rules on line if i do i feel i will be giving in to

caranua and letting mary higgens off the hook she must be under presure from the 

minister for education to make some changes . one way or another you can bet it won't 

help us in the long run were still being ripped off caranua is running out of money our 

 money . james fox.

At 22:10 on July 3, 2016, Michael power said…
I feel the excact same , that's why I won't sine it, I have a feeling that carranua will go back looking for more money,
At 19:48 on July 28, 2016, james fox said…

michiael i put up a copy of data i got of caranua on the web. james fox 

At 19:46 on January 6, 2017, james fox said…

hi michiel i don't think a hunger strike will do any good unless the media was behind you to

get your message across to the public you will only ruin your health .would it not be better to waite and see what happening when pac brings caranua to book in the coming weeks we

can see were we are going see what pac are going to do about mary higgins and caranua

mary higgins dosent give a f...k about us i have being saying oll along we can beat caranua

it will take time but you putting your health in danger is not going to solve anything we have

come a long way sending emails and spreading word of our plight . both you and i and the

many other survivers are in the same boat so think again before you go down that road 

if you do decide to go on hunger strike i will do every thing i can to help you in your fight

for justice . our day will come. james fox ..

At 10:37 on January 7, 2017, micheal said…

Hi James you make a good point, i will think hard over the weekend to ponder what you and other survivors have said to me. Thanks

At 11:25 on January 7, 2017, Barbie said…

Hi Michael, I agree with James lets wait and see what happens with PAC plus Clare Daly TD has put forward a few things in the Dail to the Minister. If you decide to go on hunger strike I will help in anyway I can to help fight for justice, and don't ever forget you're not alone and like James said our day will come!!

At 10:11 on January 9, 2017, micheal said…

Thanks i will leave it off for now and plan it out better should we need it, thanks for the support lads.

At 11:17 on January 10, 2017, Rob Northall said…

Thank God you have had second thoughts

I could not condone anyone putting their health at risk


Stay Strong!

We have each other here

You need to be a member of The Shame of Ireland to add comments!

Join The Shame of Ireland


Rob Northall created this Ning Network.


Birthdays Today

Birthdays Tomorrow


This is a Private Site

Membership is drawn from Survivors of the Irish Industrial School System their Family and Friends. Survivors of the Magdalene Laundries their Families and Friends are welcome too!

Others can follow on Twitter by Clicking the Button Bellow

Follow ShameOfIreland on Twitter

 Follow on FACE BOOK by Clicking <HERE>

Please Like this FACE BOOK Page?


  • Add Photos
  • View All



© 2022   Created by Rob Northall.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service